Tank duel between the Cologne Cathedral Panther and the T-26 Pershing

Started by Louis Gardner · 266 · 3 weeks ago
  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 3 weeks ago:

    Gary Brantley (@garybrantley)
    Thank you for your comments on the Pershing... I hear you on both counts... time and the hair thing. Mine is mostly gray now, and a bit thinner too. The years seem like they have flown by. Where did they go ?

    Stephen W Towle (@stephen-w-towle)
    Thanks for your continued support and comments. I have a patch sewn on the top front pocket of one of my Harley Davidson denim jackets.


    It pretty much sums up how I feel, and your comments about the bean counters are spot on. Let them put the rears inside a tank and see how much they enjoy getting shot at. I can guarantee you they would have had a much different opinion had this been the case.

    We were very fortunate when the M-1 Abrams was being designed. It was the first tank to my knowledge, that was designed from the onset for crew survivability as one of the main items to be considered. Speed and an incredible weapons system were the others. Ironically, (and most people don't know this), but the older M-60A3 tank was actually better at shooting targets from a stopped position, when compared to the first Abrams that entered service. In fact we used to regularly qualify our M-60 tanks using the newer (and harder) M-1 tank tables when we went to the gunnery ranges. They had targets placed at further distances, and less time allotted for each engagement. We were very good at what we did... and it showed the world in 1991 just how good we were as US Army tankers. The Abrams was much better at shooting on the move, and when it was equipped with the 120MM smooth bore, it was another huge step in the right direction. The only downside was with the larger caliber main gun, it reduced the number of rounds that were carried.

    My Dad served in both Sherman's and Perishing's when he was in Korea. He preferred the Sherman when driving on / over the hills and tiny dirt roads. He said it was more reliable too, and could go places or climb things that a Pershing could not.

    However, Dad said that he liked the Pershing for it's larger main gun and survivability. Dad said when a Sherman was hit, the crew only had seconds before it went up in flames. The downside of the Pershing was it's size. It didn't climb hills like the Sherman did, and it would not be able to operate on some of the more narrow roads... if you could call them that.

    Dad told me on his death bed, about how he had four tanks knocked out from under him when he was in the US Army during the Korean War. Land mines, artillery, mortar attacks. Once a direct hit blew the engine and transmission completely out of his tank. Several men died in his crew... and thankfully my dad was one of the lucky ones that day...

    Freedom is NOT free. I promise you that.

    Thanks again brother.

    John vd Biggelaar (@johnb)

    Thank you John. It's always nice to hear from you.

    Please stand by, as I have made some more progress today.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 3 weeks ago:

    OK boys and girls, this is what happened today at Uncle Louie's tank shop.. better known as the Iron Werke.

    I had more quality time with the Milliput putty. I was not entirely happy with how the rear tarp looked. So I mixed some more putty up in an effort to fix things.

    My luck would have it that I mixed too much up. Not wanting to waste it, I decided to do some other stuff with it.

    So here goes.



    This is what I added to the driver side left rear fender. I'm pleased with how the aerial recognition panel turned out, so I left it alone. Instead I added more putty and tried to sculpt it to look a bit more like what we see in the original film. The hard thing here, is that the shape of the tarp changes because of the air flow that is being blown on it and under it.

    The engine cooling fans are blowing hot air from inside the engine compartment, and directing it upwards and outwards through the upper grill doors on the back deck.

    Because of this, the tarp is not always the same in appearance. Outside / atmospheric winds could also change the shape of the tarp, as well as the vehicle speed as it travels forward.

    I will paint this section of the tarp tomorrow once the putty dries. Hopefully it will look better than it did before. Time will tell how it turns out. Wish me luck !


    I added some more putty to one of the laundry bags on the other rear fender. I like it better already, so I'll call this a win for me. This too will get painted once dry.

    This shows the overall view of the rear hull as things are right now.

    I had some putty left over... so,


    I decided to make the duffel bags that were stuffed on the right side of the turret. There look to be two different duffel bags here on the real Eagle 7. The they also appear to have been covered with a smaller tarp or possibly a poncho. This creates the look of a single bag on top. In one photo I grabbed from the film, you can see a smaller bag is tied off a ring on the turret roof. It looked to be very similar to this plastic one that I used from a Tamiya Infantry gear kit.

    I used some putty directly on top of the previously applied tissue paper. I wet the surface and scribed some wrinkles and lines into the putty to make it look realistic. I used several more screen grabs to do this. I turned out fairly well, and should look even better under a coat or two of paint.


    Here we can see the results of the work on the turret using the left over putty.

    Not too shabby. It's beginning to look a lot like Christmas... nope wait a minute. A lot like Eagle 7. My bad.

    It's late and I'm getting stupid and silly, so I'll sign off for now.

    Thanks for stopping by and as always,
    Comments are encouraged.

    Good night.

  • Profile Photo
    John vd Biggelaar said 1 month, 3 weeks ago:

    All looks perfect, Louis @lgardner
    Question about the milliput, the paint on yours looks perfect, my experience is that the paint over time starts to reveal cracks and the milliput color becomes visible. What kind of paint are you using on it.

  • Profile Photo
    Michael Turner said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Louis @lgardner, you have inspired me to build my first armour since the ‘80s.

    I started it last year at model camp, but goot a bit frustrated with it - armour kits seem to use five small parts where one would suffice.

    I had already done the cockpit and front suspension, but the rest is what I built today.

    The instructions would have the ammo boxes and large chest installed early in the build, but I think I will paint and weather these pieces before doing any more assembly.

  • Profile Photo
    Spiros Pendedekas said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Looks awesome, my friend @lgardner!

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    John vd Biggelaar (@johnb)
    Thank for your compliments ! I'm using the now discontinued Model Master enamels. I still have a fairly large collection that is useable. I never heard about the paint cracking before when used on Milliput. I wonder if that only happens when you use acrylics ? Hmmm. I'll be keeping an eye on this. Thank you for the heads up.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Michael Turner (@michaelt)
    It's good to hear from you, and I am very pleased to know that I have inspired you. That is the ultimate compliment, and is sincerely appreciated. It looks like you are making some very good progress on the half track. I think I would leave the boxes out too, and paint them first, install later just as you stated. Good call.

    I have seen some builders paint the interior using the early war dark gray color, and then camouflage the exterior in the 1943 onwards Dunkelgelb with the dark green and Brown colors optional for camouflage. This particular vehicle could have been painted in any number of ways, ranging from a solid early war dark gray, to anything goes late war with what you see on the box top.

    Please keep us posted with your progress.

    It's looking good !

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Spiros Pendedekas (@fiveten)
    Thank you ! Please stay posted as I have another update coming up next...

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Here is what has been done over the past few evenings.


    The tarp on the driver side rear fender was painted using a shade of dark OD Green.

    The crew storage on the turret was also carefully painted. I added another smaller gear bag on top of the two duffel bags that I constructed using Milliput. These are the ones that are stuffed into the rack on the commander’s side of the turret. I think it has a tarp covering them too.

    This shows the overall effect of how everything is painted. The main gun mantlet cover was also painted using a different green color.

    This color is very similar to what we had on the M-60’s that I served in. The cover was made of a canvas material that had a plasticized surface on top. We painted them with the same surrounding color as what our tanks were camouflaged with.


    This photo shows the opposite side of the turret.

    Then I made an attempt to take some pictures of the tank at the same angles as the pictures I took from the original Army films.

    Some of those photos were colorized so the colors we see could be different from what was actually there.




    This is a good view from the rear of the Pershing.


    This set shows the left side of the tank.


    This last set of photos shows how the turret looks. I’m close enough for what I want here.

    However I still have a few more things to add.

    There’s some storage boxes located on top of both front fenders.

    There’s a German “Jerry Can” visible on the rear deck in some of the photos.

    Lastly there’s a bracket that is securing the C ration boxes on the sides of the turret, and I have to add the radio antenna. The antenna will be pulled down and secured to one of the turret lifting rings.

    It will have a bow shape to it when done correctly.

    It’s getting closer, and so is the deadline.

    As always comments are encouraged.

    Thanks for stopping by.

  • Profile Photo
    Tom Cleaver said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    This is a really ambitious project, Louis @lgardner. You're carrying it off perfectly.

  • Profile Photo
    Spiros Pendedekas said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Really looking fantastic, my friend @lgardner!

  • Profile Photo
    John vd Biggelaar said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Superb progress again, Louis @lgardner
    The cracking I observed is indeed when using acrylic paints, Vallejo in my case.

  • Profile Photo
    George R Blair Jr said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    All the added detail and baggage looks great, Louis (@lgardner).

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Tom Cleaver (@tcinla)
    It is a project that I have wanted to do every since the first time I saw the original Army films of the encounter between the Panther and the Pershing. It has a lot of personal connections for me as well, because my Dad served for a brief time in the same parent unit that "Eagle Seven" was assigned to. He was in Company A, 36th Armored Infantry Battalion at Fort Knox after he returned from Korea in February of 1953. This unit was a part of Combat Command A, 3rd Armored Division. Clarence Smoyer was in E Company, 32nd Armored to the best of my knowledge. It was also a part of Combat Command A if memory serves me correctly.

    Dad served in Sherman's and Pershing's / Patton's while he was in Korea. I am also a former tanker myself as a crewman in M-60's and the M-1A1 Abrams. Both Dad and I were in Germany, many years divided our service though.

    Spiros Pendedekas (@fiveten)
    Thank you very much.

    John vd Biggelaar (@johnb)
    Thank you too my friend. I'm hoping the enamel will hold up a little better than the acrylics do. Time will tell if it does or not... Fingers crossed !

    George R Blair Jr (@gblair)
    Thank you my friend. I have been trying to figure out exactly what is going on with the boxes that are located on the tops of both front fenders on the Pershing. I have also made an amateurish attempt at figure painting...

    So please stick around if you want a good laugh... 😉

    Please stay tuned for another update that's coming right up.

    Thanks !

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 2 weeks ago:

    Here is what was done over the past few evenings.


    I painted the Panther figure to represent Lt. Bartelborth. I am absolutely horrible when it comes to painting figures. I rely on pure luck rather than skill. I also painted the "Jerry can" that we see on the rear deck of the Pershing.

    Here the Jerry Can is glued in place in the correct location on the rear deck of the Pershing.

    This picture shows how the Pershing looks right now. I still have to add the boxes we see in the pictures shown at the end of this posting. I have also added two ammo cans on the right front fender. They will be partially covered by some wooden and C ration boxes.

    Here we can see the Panther Commander. I have seen much better... but it fits and I am running out of time.


    This is what the Panther looks like now. It is completed other than adding the water sprinkler / gardening can which I still need to scratch build.

    Earlier I mentioned I was trying to figure out exactly what the boxes looked like on the front fenders of the Pershing. I spent some considerable time watching the film over and over again, stopping it to grab a screen shot / still. These photos were then enlarged, and finally I had my answers.



    These photos were colorized, so the colors we see represented may not be entirely accurate. They are good enough for us to get a good idea however.

    This picture is the Holy Grail photo and is also used on the cover of Adam Makos' book "Spearhead" which covers this tank battle in detail. It may be an original color photo, or it could also be colorized, as I am not sure.

    I would LOVE to someday get an autographed copy. Soon I hope. It would be the perfect addition to this project.

    Sadly, all of the men we see in this photo have since passed away. Clarence Smoyer, the gunner of Eagle 7, was the last remaining crewman alive. I believe he died in 2022, at the age of 99.

    Lest we forget the men on both sides of this tank engagement.

    There were also two civilians who were killed in a cross fire between the Pershing and a Panzer Mk IV by MG fire. They were killed in a car, travelling quickly down a street not too far from where the encounter with the Panther occurred.

    A civilian man was driving, and a civilian female was the passenger. The man died in the car, while the female died a few moments later as the US Army medics were treating her for her wounds.

    I will be covering this in the article which will be in the headlines section on March 6th, if the Good Lord is willing and I am able.

    As always, comments are encouraged.

    Thanks for stopping by and good night.