Tank duel between the Cologne Cathedral Panther and the T-26 Pershing

Started by Louis Gardner · 266 · 3 weeks ago
  • Profile Photo
    Spiros Pendedekas said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Congratulations, my friend @lgardner! What a fantastic, absolutely realistic job! Looking forward to the headlines article.
    Lest we forget.

  • Profile Photo
    John vd Biggelaar said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    This is truly amazing, Louis @lgardner
    The realism you put into it is superb.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Lou,
    Our you planning on adding a Whip Antenna? It's tied down on the turret .

  • Profile Photo
    George R Blair Jr said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Ditto from me, Louis (@lgardner). Great work on a variety of armor, as well as a bunch of scratchbuild and other additions. Well done.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Spiros Pendedekas (@fiveten)

    John vd Biggelaar (@johnb)

    Thank you both very much. I am trying very hard to make it look as realistic as possible. Last night I added some more things on the Pershing, and completed the Panther, so please stay tuned.

    Stephen W Towle (@stephen-w-towle)
    Yes I was planning to add the antenna. It was done last night. I had mentioned it earlier on a page or so back on the build journal but failed to mention it recently. Sorry for any confusion, and thanks for stopping by.

    George R Blair Jr (@gblair)
    Thanks for your kind words. I have added a few more things to both the Panther and the Pershing last night, and both involved some more scratch building. I can call the Panther "officially finished" now, and the Pershing still needs the boxes added to the front fenders, paint the headlights and tail lights, then it too will be finished.

    Please stay tuned everyone, as I have another installment coming up next.

    Thanks !

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Here’s what happened last night at the “Iron Werke”.



    I found these pictures on a website where a fellow Panther enthusiast was building his version of the Cologne tank. It shows the water can and where it was located on the side of the turret.

    The second picture shows a similar shape water can. This gave me a good idea of how big it was and how it was shaped.

    Now it was time for me to try and scratch build one.



    Here’s a few pictures showing how it was done. I used some .010 inch thick plastic sheet and rolled it up around a paint brush handle that was tapered to the correct shape.

    The plastic was really thin and it was very hard to glue together because the glue would melt the plastic if I applied too much. I discovered that the hard way.

    What you see here is the second attempt. The first one failed horribly.

    I painted the water can with a light gray color to resemble how Galvanized finishes look after exposure a while to the elements.

    I made the spout with stretched plastic sprue from a leftover tree that contained the parts for the Pershing. The actual water sprinkler part was made from the end of a parts tree and shaped into what looks similar to the one in the picture.


    Using the pictures as a reference, I glued the water can in place on the turret. It fit very nicely but I think I got the angle it was mounted off just a little. It should have been rotated a little bit more counter clockwise in order to match it perfectly.

    I was going to attempt to remove the water can and reposition it correctly, but I was worried that it might shatter if I tried. So I’m going to live with it as is.

    There’s a small crease in the can under the handle, but I left it as is because it makes it look more realistic.

    The water can fit perfectly in the position and this was mounted on the spare track center guides and the welded on track hanger blocks.






    These pictures show how the Panther looks now that it is completed.

    I think it will look better in the article when it is photographed then.


    Then it was time to switch gears and start working on the Pershing.

    I was in the zone and I didn’t get any pictures of how I made the brackets that held up the C ration boxes. First thing that I did was to bend a plastic square shaped strip into the correct shape and size. I used a plastic strip that measures .020 X .010. Once it was glued in place, I removed the C ration boxes from the turret so I could paint them and not get paint on the boxes.

    You can see the results in the pictures.

    Then it was time to build the radio antenna. Here I used a plastic tree from an American armor kit and heated it. It was stretched out until it was the appropriate size and thickness.

    Next I used some small string and I pulled it apart. This gave me four smaller diameter pieces that were about the same diameter as the rope that held the antenna down as is visible in the pictures of the Pershing.

    The final part was to add a little strip of tissue paper to represent the improvised warning that the crew had tied to the rope.



    Next I tied the rope off on the turret lifting ring, but it was too long. The angle was wrong and the antenna was too high.

    So I had to remove the rope shorten the rope a little.
    The last thing I needed to do was bend the antenna itself a little bit and make it look like it was almost parallel with the ground.

    I was very pleased with how it looked when done.


    Here you can see the difference.

    The final result is almost spot on to what we see in the pictures.

    Here’s a look at the tank from the same angle as one of the screenshots I took from the original Army film.

    It is looking very close to what we see in the original Army footage.

    I still have to paint the tail lights and the headlights.

    Scratch build the boxes and then install them on top of the front fenders.

    Then the Pershing will be done too.

    As always comments are encouraged.

    Thanks for following along and hopefully I will get this done tonight.

    Then it will be in the headlines on March 6th.

    Take care everyone.

  • Profile Photo
    Spiros Pendedekas said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    That's an awesome water can and really great progress on the Pershing, my friend @lgardner!

  • Profile Photo
    Gary Brantley said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Very cool, Louis! 👍 That's some good scratchwork; what was the water sprinkler can used for on the Panther? 🤔

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Lou,

    The idea of making a huge diorama is out of the question. What if you where to take foam board and blow up your photos of the back round of the city and mount them to the board. Place your models where each tank was sitting and compress the scene. Or blow up each photo with the corresponding tank and back round.

    The antenna and the water sprinkler add to the story. Gives more for the eye to see and ask those who, what and why questions of how tankers personalized their ride. Keep up the good work.

  • Profile Photo
    John vd Biggelaar said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    That Panther looks really amazing, Louis @lgardner
    The water can is made beautifully, very realistic.
    Also the work on antenna on the Pershing is fantastic.

  • Profile Photo
    Michael Turner said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    G’day Louis (@lgardner),

    Your attention to detail is fantastic. I particularly like your watering can.

    Your figure painting is fine - that is something I try and avoid, too. But, I will have to think about if I’ll add figures to my build.

    Here is an update, by the way.

    After I took the photos, I realised I had forgotten to add the machine guns either side of the driver/radio operator positions.

  • Profile Photo
    Paul Barber said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Just fantastic, Louis! We’ve chatted about this already, but it’s the details that make a build and every piece of armour is different by our reckoning! This is unique and special - really well done!

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Spiros Pendedekas (@fiveten)
    Thank you ! The water can did turn out OK, but it was very hard to do. I guess I got lucky...

    Gary Brantley (@garybrantley)
    Thanks for the kind words. It was not easy to make the water can. My best guess about why it was carried is based on personal experience as a tanker. It was probably used as a make shift shower nozzle for the crew... for use in the field when they had time available for personal hygiene. They would probably fill it up and pour it on each other to rinse off the soap. You would be surprised at the ingenuity some crews can come up with to get clean. Please keep in mind that these tankers in WW2 often had to go several months at a time before they could bathe. The longest we ever had to go was around 45 days or so. It's not too much fun living like that. Infantry grunts and artillery crews experience similar circumstances. Basically any of the combat arms units have to operate like this, some more than others. I would imagine that the support units do this as well, but they probably have better access to bathing facilities or base camps than we did.

    Thanks again.

    Stephen W Towle (@stephen-w-towle)
    Yes I had thought about doing this with a picture on a poster board. But I have two problems. My printer doesn't work, and if it did, I wouldn't be able to enlarge the photos big enough to work. So I checked into sending pictures out to several printing companies, and they were going to charge me anywhere between $35 to $60 per picture to get them to the correct sizes that I needed.

    So I purchased some foam board sheets and have plans to make the walls and cobblestone streets myself. This will be a bit time consuming, but I believe the end result will look better, because it will have a 3 dimensional effect and since the final photos will be taken outside, it will cast shadows making the pictures look more realistic. Plus I can scratch build some piles of rubble. These rubble piles wouldn't be permanently attached to the road, so I could place them and even rotate them around to different locations to change things up. I plan on adding tram car tracks in one section of the cobble stone road base.

    If not for the excessive prices I probably would have gone the way you mentioned. Good idea, and I may still need to get one picture done this way. It would be used as the backdrop behind the Panther tank as it was about to be fired upon by the Pershing. It's kind of hazy background, and I think it has a little of the Cologne Cathedral involved.

    I wanted to add as many details to these two tanks, so they would look as realistic as I possibly could do. These little items do indeed bring a bit of reality to what it's like to be a tanker... and why we do the things we do.

    Thanks for stopping by. Please check back soon, as I have another update coming up on the Pershing.

    John vd Biggelaar (@johnb)
    Hello John, and thank you for the kind words. I am very pleased with how these items have turned out. The antenna was not too hard to do, but building the water can was. Thanks again for your continued support and comments. Take care my friend.

    Michael Turner (@michaelt)
    First off, thanks for stopping by again. Secondly, you are doing a wonderful job with your Halftrack. It looks exceptionally nice. It will get only better from here. Thank you for posting your pictures here and sharing them with us. Going from memory, they had a pair of MP-40's mounted on the sidewalls next to the driver and radio operator front seats.

    If you can't install them now, you might simply be able to say they were in use, or being carried by the crew. I'm not sure what kind of brackets they had to secure these weapons to the walls though. You still may be able to install them with some careful work and a lot of patience. Good luck and keep us posted with more updates as they happen. Thanks.

    We had several different style brackets that held our .45 caliber M-3 "grease guns" in the M-60's. They were fun to shoot by the way...

    Paul Barber (@yellow10)
    Thank you so very much for your kind words. Yes I remember our conversations well. In my old Armored Cavalry unit, no two tanks were ever the same. We had minor differences between each tank, (and other vehicles for that matter). When our tanks were camouflaged, you could pick out minor differences between the patterns in the paint colors. We sprayed them most of the time, and occasionally brush painted them once in a while. I liked the way they looked best in a solid overall desert sand color personally.

    Then the crews would store their gear in the bustle rack behind the turret. What we couldn't fit there, we would store inside the turret and hull if we could. We also put things in the various sponson boxes and on the outside of the turret using straps just like how the crew of the Pershing did with their tank. The variations were minor, but noticeable if you really looked closely. Some things never change...

    Please be safe with the hurricane that should be making landfall near your city any time now. Please let me know how things are going for you if you can.

    Take care my friend and please keep in touch if possible.

    I have an update coming up next, so please stay tuned...

    Thanks you .

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    Here is what was done today on the Pershing.



    Using the zoomed in pictures I took from my screenshots of the original Army film, I was able to determine roughly what the boxes were, and how they were mounted on the front fenders. This shows the boxes on the driver side fender.

    I also painted the headlights using a Molotow chrome pen. This worked exceptionally well. Close inspection of the pictures shows that the larger box has what appears to be a bullet hole in it. The contents inside this box have leaked out, and stained the box. It appears to be constructed of cardboard.

    However, the top box is wooden, and has a metal handle. It was held in place by canvas straps. In these photos, you can see the metal strap, the bullet holes and the dent in the front fender side / dust skirt.


    This shows the details of the boxes and how they were mounted on the bow gunner / radio operator side fender. In some photos, you can see what appears to be a white piece of cloth. I tried to replicate this feature with some white tissue paper. This side has a section of rope holding the boxes together that is connected to the head light guard. Then the boxes are held down to the fender with a flat canvas strap.

    You can also see the headlight has been painted with Molotow chrome here as well.


    The tail lights and the black out drive "cat eyes" were painted using a tooth pick. The black out drive is on top, and were used at night when tactics required them.






    These pictures show the completed Pershing ! Yes it is finally done and it's a good feeling.


    I wanted to show the difference in size between the Pershing and the Panther.

    The hull was longer and the Panther was a little taller in overall height than the Pershing was.


    The Pershing was a little wider than the Panther was. This would have been bad for the Allies if they had to use the railways to transport these tanks in Europe in the later part of the war. The tank would likely have been too wide to fit through tunnels if needed.

    I will be posting the article later on today.

    This event that unfolded near the Cologne Cathedral happened 80 years ago today.

    Lest we forget that freedom is not free. Many people lost their lives on this date in 1945. I will be covering several of them in my upcoming article, so please stay tuned for that.

    I will continue on with this build journal, so that I can complete the pair of Sherman's both of which were knocked out by the Panther prior to the engagement with the Pershing.

    I will also be finishing up the Panzer Mk IV that was disabled by the Pershing by shooting through a building wall. The falling rubble and building debris damaged the Panzer 4 so they could not turn the turret. The tank was abandoned by two crew members, while the others were talking about using it as a Stug IV assault gun type fighting vehicle since the turret could not be turned. I believe the tank was abandoned once two crew members left it.

    Plus I will be building Hollywood style building walls and cobblestone street photo shoot bases for the final article.

    The final article will go into more details, and will have every tank involved included.

    Please stay tuned, for this ride is only half done.

    Thank you very much for everyone who has been following this adventure going back in time.

    Take care and I hope to hear from you.

    As always comments are encouraged.

    Good night everyone.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 1 month, 1 week ago:

    These Panther and Pershing tanks have been posted in the headline section. I will come back later today and edit the article, because once again life gets in the way of our hobby. So please check back at take another look at the article later today.

    80 Years ago today Cologne Cathedral tank duel between a Pershing and a Panther tank
    Here's the link to the article if you are interested. Thanks again for following this build journal, and I will continue to update the other tanks that were involved here on this thread. These tanks include Lt. Kellner's Sherman M-4A1 and another unknown M-4A3. There is also a Panzer Mk IV J late version. All of these tanks were damaged or destroyed during this epic engagement.