Brewster F2A Buffalo VMF-221

Started by Frank Steffens · 34 · 7 years ago
  • Profile Photo
    Frank Steffens said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    So, I'm plodding away at this punishment of a kit. I manage to fight back after punch this thing throws at me...until tonight. Having attached the life raft tube and headrest behind the cockpit, and discovering, with absolutely no surprise that the two uprights that are supposed to meet over that assembly don't, and really, why would they, and when I get them to meet, I'm going to have to fill the sinkholes and the ridiculous seam that will no doubt result. It was then that I thought that I should get the canopy and make sure that it would fit over this mess after all this trouble. It was then that I realized...

    I can't find the clear parts sprue.

    Worse, I can't remember ever having SEEN the clear parts sprue.

    I tend to do things in a particular order when opening a kit and I have a special place where the clear parts of my kits go so they don't get damaged. They weren't there. I also don't remember inspecting them and putting them in their place like I always do.

    I then proceeded to rip apart my workshop, open every kit that's recently come in, I dumped out the garbage, I pulled everything apart. Nothing.

    I'm not proud of what came next.

    I carefully removed all of the parts that I had cleaned and placed on fixtures for painting from their perches. I then gently placed the engine, wings and fuselage half/cockpit subassemblies with the other parts, and I proceeded to break every single piece into tiny pieces and throw it in the trash.

    What's worse, I'm not even mad. It was cathartic. It felt good to be rid of that kit.

    I build for enjoyment. I prefer to build well engineered kits that are designed well and reasonably accurate. If I'm REALLY interested in the subject, I'll muddle my way through the fitting, sanding, filling, filing to get what I want. This was one of those kits. It was within my skills and abilities, but I not only wasn't enjoying it, I was dreading it. I usually am happy to get down to the workshop, put on some music and have hours pass by like minutes. Not this time. I found myself looking for excuses not to go downstairs.

    To be honest, rather than the sinking feeling of dread that I would feel on a project I was enjoying upon realizing that I'm missing parts, I actually felt relieved.. It was as if I was let off the hook. I could have looked around for a replacement, but i had no desire to do so. Now I have to think about what I can build for this GB. I have Tamiya's and Hasegawa's A6M2 kits, as well as a Rufe. I'll have a look at them and see if any of them have markings for a Midway combatant.

  • Profile Photo
    Bernard E. Hackett, Jr. said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Frank, if you're feeling ambitious, how bout a crosskit? Cut off the SH later nose and engine, mate it to the front of the Tamiya? Be like using the conversation kit on the Tamiya? Think that's the difference, longer nose, different engine, at least cosmetically. Made the -3 heavier, imagine that.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Wow Frank that's bad news, (I think)...

    I have had some kits fight me like that. Sometimes you just do what you have to do. If you're not having fun while building something, then something is wrong. This is supposed to be a hobby. Relaxing and fun.

    Another project will come along...

    However Bernard has a point. If these parts are still salvageable.

    If not, it may not be too hard to convert an older Tamiya Buffalo into a dash 3. As far as I know it's a fairly simple process that involves cutting the nose along a seam and adding a small 7/32 inch (I think) wide strip of plastic, then joining the nose back on. It would probably be easier if the strip you're adding was the same approximate thickness as the original fuselage parts. Then you could add some stiffeners inside to help make it a strong joint.

    There is a slight difference on the canopy too, but nothing that can't be done.

    I've thought about doing this same thing to one of my older Tamiya Buffalos that I built many years ago. It needs a re build, especially on some of the fuselage seams, and has a lot of incorrect colors on it.

    My skill set back then wasn't the greatest...

    Who knows, inspiration happens at the weirdest times...

  • Profile Photo
    Frank Steffens said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Thanks gentlemen, but the parts of the SH kit are already in the garbage. I'll think of something tonight.

  • Profile Photo
    Frederick J Seitz III said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Well, with the apparent end of the "Buffalo", may I suggest either an A6M2, or an Aichi D3Y1, "Val"? Both kits are available from our local hobby store, and Hasegawa makes a really nice kit of either... I did notice one A6M, but it was an Aleutian attacker, not a Midway. I also don't recall seeing a "Val" on the list at all... just my two cents

  • Profile Photo
    Frank Steffens said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    I'm looking into an A6M2. I have both Hasegawa's and Tamiya's in my stash. I'm looking up birds I can model and if there's any decals I'd need to get, I can paint the Hinomarus, but I'll have to see what I can get as far as tail codes

  • Profile Photo
    Tom Bebout said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Wow what lousy luck Frank. Only threw away one kit that I remember, had the same feelings as well. The bright side is the sky's the limit now, keep on modeling my friend and have some fun doing it.

  • Profile Photo
    Bernard E. Hackett, Jr. said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    I've been looking for Aleutian Rufes, and photos of them are (for me, anyhow) hard to find. That other site has a link to some Aleutian aircraft model builds which I stuck in a note the other day, one of which might fill the bill. I favor the Tamiya version, being an old school guy. I've had one for years, and this might be the time. Why not?

    I've also been thinking that perhaps a use for half done, never gonna go back to kits is in a dio, as a hangar queen, wreck, pushed off into the tall grass at the edge of the runway. Just like in the real places. "Out to pasture" Sheep grazing around it, bushes growing out of the cockpit, ad infinitum. Parts missing, panels off, wingtip missing. Vengence of the modeler!

  • Profile Photo
    Frank Steffens said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Okie doke. I have decided that I will be building Tamiya's 1/48 A6M2 as D11-105 No.6 Koku Sentai aircraft carrier Junyo as part of the attack on Dutch Harbor, Unalaska Island, June 3-4, 1942. In order to replicate the tail codes, I'll have to butcher a pair of decals from the Tamiya Rufe.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Frank,
    This is another great choice. I think you will enjoy this build. Mine went together pretty quick and didn't need any filler.

    Earlier I built the "Koga" or Akutan Zero which was very similar to the plane you mentioned. I did some research on the plane and found some pretty neat photos of the one I modeled mine after. The Koga Zero has the tail markings "DI-108" and flew from the Ryujo, which was alongside the Junyo.

    Here's a link that will show you a lot of the colors I chose after some considerable research.

    http://imodeler.com/groups/75th-anniversary-battle-of-midway-group-build/forum/topic/tamiya-148-scale-mitsubishi-a6m2-zero-as-flown-by-petty-officer-1st-class-koga/

    Some artists renditions and decal sheets show the plane with yellow fuselage and rudder / fin stripes. After I carefully studied all of the photos I could find I am beginning to doubt that these are true representations. I explained all of this during my build thread.

    Please check it out and see what you decide.

    I hope this will help you during your build. If I can be of any assistance please don't hesitate to shoot me a PM.

  • Profile Photo
    Frederick J Seitz III said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Frank, if the letters are red, I have a sheet you can use. I used them on my "Claude"
    DII-109. Same set also comes is Black, White and Yellow, available from the sprue crew

  • Profile Photo
    Frank Steffens said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Thanks Freddie, I should be able to combine the tail code decals from the Tamiya Rufe to get DII-105, unless I screw the pooch, which has been my experience lately, and then I will definitely take you up on your offer!

  • Profile Photo
    Tom Bebout said 7 years, 8 months ago:

    Nice choice Frank, I'm sure you'll have a better experience with this kit.

  • Profile Photo
    Frank Steffens said 7 years, 7 months ago:

    I'm going to start a new thread for the A6M2. In the meantime, I've already cleaned up all of the parts and am starting to paint. Im doing the cockpit in Tamiya XF71 Green, and I know that the wheel wells of Mitsubishi Zeros aren't supposed to be aotake, but darn near every picture I'm finding of finished kits had the wheel wells in what looks like X13 metallic blue. Does anyone know of a good reference pic that can point me in the direction of the right color? I found one picture of a wrecked plane and the wheel wells looked very close to the XF 71 green.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 7 years, 7 months ago:

    Hey Frank.
    Here's a link to another website that specializes in WW2 Japanese aircraft.

    http://www.j-aircraft.com/faq/navy_message_board.htm

    There are 5 pages here on nothing but the A6M Zero ! There is a whole lot of information there on colors and markings. They are stating that from preserved relics and parts recovered from crashed planes that the colors are very close to FS 16350 or FS 34201. Another close approximation is German RLM 02.

    I spent several days looking through this information, taking notes, etc. before I started painting on my "Koga" or "Akutan" Zero here on the Midway Group build.

    Here's a link on the build which also has some decent color photos taken from my Federal Standards color book, and various photos of the plane through the building process.

    http://imodeler.com/groups/75th-anniversary-battle-of-midway-group-build/forum/topic/tamiya-148-scale-mitsubishi-a6m2-zero-as-flown-by-petty-officer-1st-class-koga/?topic_page=1&num=15

    As far as replicating the blue / green "Aotake" protective finish, this is how I do it:

    I paint the area in a bright aluminum or silver shade. The brighter the better...

    Then I use Tamiya X-23 "Clear Blue" and spray the silver / aluminum area. I go back to various places and spray it again to make the clear blue thicker in these areas. It will give the clear blue a variation in color typically found in "Aotake". Then I randomly use X-24 "Clear Yellow" using the same process. This gives the 'Clear Blue" a little greenish colored tint in the areas where you used the yellow.

    This is another link below, that shows how someone else does the same process as I described to you. (But they also have some decent photos of similar relic parts).

    http://www.partworkmodels.co.uk/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=173&t=7559

    Here's a photo of the variations found in the "Aotake" finish from several relic pieces.

    The first picture shows quite a variation in color and came from the forum at "Large Scale Planes"

    The second photo came from Ron Coles website. He features relic parts combined with his art for sale... very cool stuff here too.

    Please go to the J Aircraft website and do some reading. Draw your own conclusions, then paint it in the colors you think are correct.

    I went with FS 34201 by Model Master on my build. It's a color called SAC Bomber Tan. The bad news is that it supposedly has been discontinued... Get it while you can.

    I also used FS 34096 for the cockpit color since it was a Mitsubishi built plane and FS 35042 for the cowling and area under the canopy. This is the same color used by the US Navy during WW2, as "Dark Sea Blue"... believe it or not.

    I sincerely hope this helps.