Thanks Spiros (@fiveten), George (@gblair), and John (@johnb).
George, This time around it was primarily Vallejo Model Color with the shading being Model Air. I have found that using Vallejo Flow Improver as the thinning agent works best for airbrushing, but it is a fine line between not enough thinner and too much, so it pays to test it until it is spraying the way you want it to.
However, from what my own testing shows, and what I have seen, it really comes down to the best color match or the best choice for mixing to get a color match because paint colors seem to be all over the board when it comes to matching what is supposed to be a standard color. I am sure you have experienced this as well.
As for durability, I have found that Vallejo dries quickly to touch, but needs longer to dry fully and does need a clear protective coat. The protective coat is not usually a problem since I am doing that for other reasons anyway. I've had real good results with Alclad Aqua Gloss and VMS Satin (both are water based acrylics).
The one thing I really like about Vallejo is the choice of colors to choose from (and the lack of odor). Atom paints, I am still not sure about. I only have a few that I have used so far. They seem to spray well, but the metallics at least still look more like paint than metal. However, I have not tried very many of them and am leaving myself open to trying more.