North American P-51B Mustang (Tamiya 1/48) versus A-36 Apache (AM 1/48)

Started by John vd Biggelaar · 482 · 2 months ago
  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 4 months, 1 week ago:

    TC, I believe in one of your earlier build reviews of this kit, you used a P-39 prop. I'm still looking for that sweet piece.

    This kit once, you start falling down that rabbit hole with regards to accuracy it falls short. I believe, that the cannon armed Mustangs that the AAF used for the North Africa campaign would have a dust filter mounted on top. The kit supplied nose is for a British aircraft fighting in the ETO. You would have buy a A-36 kit for its dust filtered nose do surgery. However, for now if your married to plastic kits this is the only game in town. Although, Eduard is developing a Mustang B/C kit. They may have enough info from developing that kit to do a Allison powered kit.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 2 months, 3 weeks ago:

    I've replaced the prop with a P-39 prop. Move the yellow stripes. The kits cannons will be replaced with ones from a Master Modeler set. The landing gear is from a Monogram P-51D. The wheels are from Eduard Brassin. The kit canopy is too small. Just enough wiggle room to not be seated tightly and true. I've gotten a Tamiya replacement.

    ACA really did not do the research on Mah Sweet Eva Lee. If your planning on follow the photos.They did a generic approach that may have been done at the beginning of the North African campaign.

    2 attached images. Click to enlarge.

  • Profile Photo
    Spiros Pendedekas said 2 months, 3 weeks ago:

    Looks excellent so far, my friend @stephen-w-towle! Great that you sourced a P-39 prop, along with other goodies. Looking forward to your next steps!

  • Profile Photo
    John vd Biggelaar said 2 months, 3 weeks ago:

    Great progress, Stephen @stephen-w-towle
    Lots of replacements which will definitely improve the looks.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    Stephen W Towle (@stephen-w-towle)
    It's been a while since I have checked in... You have done some great work here, and I will keep it in mind about the different propeller you used. I have recently picked up an Accurate Miniatures P-51A and I want to build all three planes in a cool picture that Dana Bell used on the cover of one of his books.


    It was taken in color, during the War somewhere over Florida...

    Your posting has inspired me to get back to work on my previous Mustang builds. So please take a look for some updates on the "LOU IV" 1/32 scale Revell Mustang, and the planes in the 1/48 scale Mustang Kindergarten soon.

    I have now repainted the D Day invasion stripes on "LOU IV" and plan on painting the Dark Blue and OD Green soon...

  • Profile Photo
    George R Blair Jr said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    Your model looks terrific, Stephen (@stephen-w-towle). It is amazing how many subtle ( and not so subtle), changes need to be made when you start digging into the references. You really begin to understand that these planes never had a static design, but were constantly changed and improved on the assembly-line.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    Spiros (@Fiveten ), your comments are a pick me up. I get a kick out reading how a guy half way around the world collected models and visited Hobby stores over the years and can be so productive in making kits. I've been doing the same for over 40yrs. Delete the word productive and add the word slow. But, I always get where your coming from.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    John vd Biggelaar ( @johnb ), your comments and your Tamiya build and its progress have all helped contribute to my build.

  • Profile Photo
    Chuck A. Villanueva said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    Rumpelstiltskin here, how I missed this remarkable thread of several craftsmen at their best on the dynamic Mustang. Especially over a year and still somehow missed any of the updates posted throughout the year. As I slumbered over the vast info or your venture, your sharing of info and skills are well documented with a bond which makes this hobby much more enjoyable sharing each others tehcniques and reviews as you proceed on your indivividual subjects. Another point is those who are not participating but still share any issues of each model project in progress pointing out any hiccups they may have encountered and the help to advise about any issues. But in the end an amazing group effort for everyone involved. Thanks for sharing and keep it up, I'm strapped in now for the final finish.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    Louis Gardner (@Igardner) I love the idea. Basically, when Accurate Miniature was in their prime their Allison powered kits from the fire wall on back are pretty good depending on which version you choose. As you know from past experience this kit is a simple build and I find it to be a fun kit to build. If your planning on taking it to the next level it's all in the details and what your creative mind can do to make things more interesting for yourself and the viewer. It can be a shake and bake kit fun wise or a platform for customizing it into something special.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    George R Blair Jr (@gblair) good observation the aircraft was always evolving to meet the needs of the situation at hand.

    When the AAF was doing day light bombing with out the need for escort along with the Brits doing their bombing at night the losses of airmen once the press got a hold of some of the numbers forced the AAF to take a closer look at the Mustang. Also, the Brits were facing the Fw-190 which was putting pressure on the RAF and their Mk V Spitfires. The politics and the reality of combat helped change the technology of the Mustang into adapting the Rolls Royce Merlin engine. I still like doing this Allison powered version. Allison engines could be abused more than Merlin powered engines and they could pull the a/c farther running at lower rpms. Considering the U.S. entered the war late and the number of years of development for such a short period of time relative today's aircraft is amazing.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    The 20mm cannons appear to have the recoil spring moved to the fairings.

    2 attached images. Click to enlarge.

  • Profile Photo
    Stephen W Towle said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    Here is a photo of a Cannon armed P-51 1A. With the recoil springs mounted in the front A/c is being tested by NAA and the intake scoop has a coke bottle shape.

    1 attached image. Click to enlarge.

  • Profile Photo
    Louis Gardner said 2 months, 2 weeks ago:

    Stephen W Towle (@stephen-w-towle)
    These are some excellent observations. Sometimes the information we need is right there in front of us. All we have to do is look.

    Outstanding work.

    I will take your word of encouragement and add another Pony to the Kindergarten.


    This is the kit that I’m using to make the Mustang that is in the photo with the Thunderbolt and the Lightning.

    This will be the Thunderbolt and I will have to modify the cowling vents.

    This will be used for the Lighting. I have decals for the exact plane in the picture. I’ll have to scrounge up some numbers for the Mustang and the Thunderbolt.

    I have started working on finishing up my 1/32 LOU IV as well.

    Thank you for the encouragement.

  • Profile Photo
    George R Blair Jr said 2 months, 1 week ago:

    Great use of photos to get the info you need, Stephen W Towle (@stephen-w-towle). Looks like you will be busy, Louis (@lgardner). Looking forward to the continuing story of everyone's builds.